Rules
CFM League Rules Template: Copy, Edit, Post
Every league argument you will ever have is one your rules document didn't settle in advance. This is a complete template, section by section, with the choices most leagues make and the reasons behind them. Copy it, cut what you don't need, and post it before the first advance.
Updated November 15, 2026 · 11 min read · By the FranchiseHuddle team
A good CFM rulebook covers seven things: league settings, sportsmanship, scheduling and the advance, forced wins and sims, trades, the salary cap and free agency, and discipline. Write each rule so two owners reading it reach the same answer, put numbers on everything (hours, margins, counts), and say who decides when a rule doesn't fit.
How to use this template
Rules exist to settle arguments before they start, so every rule below is written to be checkable: a number, a deadline, or a named person who decides. "Don't run up the score" starts fights. "No passing plays when leading by 28 or more in the fourth quarter" ends them.
- Cut ruthlessly. A 12-person casual league needs half of this. A 32-team competitive league needs all of it, plus its own history.
- Keep the numbers, change the values. If you think 24 hours is too short, make it 36. Just don't delete the number.
- Post it where people will find it: a read-only
#ruleschannel in Discord, pinned, with a changelog at the bottom. - Vote on changes in the offseason, not mid-season, and never retroactively.
Tip: number every rule (3.2, 5.4). When a dispute comes up, "see rule 5.4" ends the conversation faster than a paragraph.
1. League settings
State the settings up front so nobody signs up for a different league than the one you run. Typical choices:
- Skill level: the game's highest difficulty for user-vs-user and user-vs-CPU games, unless your league is explicitly casual.
- Quarter length: most leagues play 8 to 10 minute quarters with the accelerated clock on, which keeps play counts close to a real game.
- Injuries: on. Salary cap: on. Trade approval: commissioner.
- Rosters: current rosters or a fantasy draft, decided before anyone joins.
- Platform: which console the league plays on, and whether owners on other platforms can join.
- Edits: no edits to players, ratings or contracts by anyone, ever, except the commissioner applying a reward the league voted on.
2. Sportsmanship
Sportsmanship rules are the ones owners argue about most, so they need the hardest numbers.
- Running up the score. Once a team leads by 28 or more in the second half, it runs the ball and stops going for it on fourth down unless the game is still in doubt. Put your own margin here, and say what counts as "in doubt".
- Fourth downs. Many leagues limit fourth-down attempts to realistic situations: inside the opponent's 40 with 4 or fewer yards to go, or when trailing in the fourth quarter.
- Two-point conversions only when the score makes it a real-football decision.
- Exploits. No plays or formations the league has listed as cheese. Keep that list short and specific, and update it each season as the meta changes.
- Force-feeding. No targeting one receiver on most passing plays for a whole game. Agree a share (for example, no more than 40% of targets) so it can be checked against the box score.
- Quitting. Quitting a game in progress is an automatic loss and a strike.
Whatever numbers you choose, the box score has to be able to show them. A rule nobody can check becomes a he-said-she-said thread.
3. Scheduling and the advance
- Advance schedule. The league advances every [24 / 48] hours at [time and time zone]. Post the exact time with every advance.
- League time zone. All times in rules and scheduling are in [ET]. A time without a time zone isn't a scheduled time.
- Making contact. Both owners reach out within [12] hours of the advance, in the game's scheduling thread, with at least two times they can play.
- Proof of effort. Scheduling happens in the league's channels, not in DMs, so the commissioner can see who tried.
- Early advance. If every user-vs-user game is played, the commissioner may advance early.
- Games against the CPU are played before the advance, or the owner is sim'd and takes a strike.
The full reasoning, and how to make an advance schedule people actually keep, is in our scheduling guide.
4. Forced wins and sims
When a game isn't played by the deadline, the commissioner decides it. Write down how, before it happens:
- Forced win to the owner who showed clear effort in the scheduling thread (offered times, replied promptly) when the other didn't.
- Sim (or a fair sim, if your league uses one) when both owners tried and couldn't find a time, or when neither did.
- Strikes to an owner who never replied.
- Rulings are posted publicly with a one-line reason.
Forced wins are where leagues lose trust. Two habits prevent most of it: decide from the thread history, not from memory or DMs, and post the reason every time, even when it's obvious.
5. Trades
- Both owners post the full trade in
#tradesbefore it is processed in the game. - Review. Trades are approved by [the commissioner / a trade committee of three owners / a league vote] within [24] hours. A committee member never reviews a trade involving their own team.
- Trades with CPU teams are [not allowed / allowed only with commissioner approval]. The game's AI can be talked into deals no human would make.
- Draft picks may be traded up to [two] seasons ahead.
- No trade-backs. A player traded away can't be traded back to the same team for [one season].
- Trade deadline matches the game's deadline, or is earlier.
- Cap check. A trade that leaves a team over the cap is rejected.
Setting up review so it stops lopsided deals without slowing every trade down is covered in the trade rules guide.
6. Salary cap, contracts and free agency
- Position changes. No changing a player's position to lower his re-signing price (the classic quarterback-to-punter trick). Position changes for real depth reasons need commissioner approval.
- Free-agent contract length is capped at [3] years.
- Star free agents. Each team may sign no more than [2] free agents rated [80] or higher per offseason.
- Cutting to dodge the cap (releasing and re-signing the same player cheaper) is not allowed.
- Over the cap after any move: the owner gets a warning and [one advance] to fix it, then a penalty.
- Free-agency nights happen at a scheduled time with everyone online; see rule 3.1 for the time zone.
Why these house rules exist, and the ones worth adding for a competitive league, are in the salary cap guide.
7. Discipline
- Strikes. Rule breaks earn strikes. [Three] strikes in a season means removal.
- Suspensions can bench an owner's player for a set number of games, or sim an owner's games for a stretch.
- Using a suspended player is its own strike.
- The commissioner decides anything the rules don't cover, and posts the ruling publicly. Repeated rulings become rules at the next offseason vote.
- Appeals go to [the co-commissioner / a committee] within [24] hours.
8. Joining, leaving and inactivity
- New owners read the rules and confirm in
#rulesbefore they get a team. - An owner who misses [two] user games in a row without notice is replaced.
- An owner leaving mid-season gives [48] hours' notice so the team can be handed over.
- The league keeps a waitlist of replacement owners.
Most leagues don't end in a blowup; they fade. The guide to keeping a league active covers what actually prevents that.
Where FranchiseHuddle does the work
Everything above works with a spreadsheet and a lot of patience. These are the parts FranchiseHuddle takes off your plate:
Discipline & rule enforcement
Keep the league fair, automatically.
Self-scheduling matchups
The league schedules itself — no more chasing people for a kickoff time.
Trades & Discord Votes
Mutual-consent trades of players and draft picks the league actually approves.
Salary Cap
Every club's cap room, and the tools to enforce it.
Integrity watchdog
Catch the shady roster edit before it costs you the league.
Commissioner result overrides
Settle no-shows and disputes cleanly, in the open.
Questions
What is a CFM league?
CFM stands for connected franchise mode: an online franchise where up to 32 people each run a team in the same league, playing each other's games on the console and advancing week by week. Leagues are usually organised on Discord.
How long should a league rulebook be?
As short as it can be while still answering the questions your league actually argues about. Most good rulebooks fit on one screen per section. If a rule has never been needed, cut it.
Who enforces the rules?
The commissioner, ideally with a co-commissioner or small committee for appeals and for trades involving the commissioner's own team. What matters most is that rulings are public and consistent.
Your league is two minutes from running itself.
Create a free league, connect EA, and watch the site and Discord update themselves. Upgrade to hands-off automation whenever you're ready.